|
Home
Professional
P.R.
Writing
Speaking
Geeking
Terms
Other areas
About Tom
Contact info
Tom's other sites
bandwidthpr.com
spamcon.org
openppc.org
popcomputers.com
Mailing lists:
Tgeller-personal
Tgeller-business
Suespammers
|
|
Up one level | To Tom Geller's writings | Home
Website reviews for The Net: Travel
Please note that the writing samples below were written around
February 1996, and many of the sites reviewed have disappeared,
moved, or changed. -- Tom Geller
007 Travel
American Airlines
ANZA Travel
Boat To Bolivia
Bridge
China
The Electronic Embassy
Expotel
France Travel Tourism Tours Festivals Studies
The French Travel Gallery & Hotel Reservation Center
GNN Travelers' Center American Borders
GNN Travelers' Center Currency Converter
GNN Travelers' Center
Guyana Gateway
Have Toothbrush Will Travel
Healthy Flying
InfoHub Travel Guide
The Internet Guide to Travel
Internet Way
Life Following the Dead
Mirage Resorts
Preview Vacations
Project Candide
Rec.Travel Library: Worldwide Travel and Tourism
Southwest Adventures
Southwest Airlines
Travel Source
Travel Weekly
U.S State Department Travel Warnings
Walt Disney World
Web Travel Review
007 Travel
Lots of forms. Lots and lots and lots of forms. That's what you'll
find at the 007 Travel site, which acts mainly as a device for
a crafty travel agency to collect information on your travel plans.
Want to know the lowest prices on flights to London? Fill out
a form. Renting a car overseas? Fill out a form. Need to know
where the 007 Travel agency is located? Sorry, you're out of luck:
That information isn't available. You'll find some useful information
here, such as a list of moderately priced international hotels
and restaurants, but otherwise this is a mess of broken links,
missing graphics, and mystery. WARNING: Never send your credit
card number to a company that doesn't give its phone number or mailing address.
Content: Good
Aesthetic: Poor
TechnoSmart: Poor
Author: Tom Geller
Back to top
American Airlines
Now we know what all those flight attendants do when they're not
serving drinks and emptying barf bags: They're writing HTML code.
That's the only way American could have produced such a mammoth
site, with pages on more than 50 subjects such as flight schedules,
fleet composition, and corporate structure. Unfortunately, AA's
most useful wing -- the online ticket-booking service known as
Sabre -- isn't directly accessible via the Web site.
Content: Excellent
Aesthetic: Excellent
TechnoSmart: Good
Author: Tom Geller
Back to top
ANZA Travel
I'm a sucker for unusual travel. That's why I like places like
ANZA: instead of the silly and overdone tedium of Dickens' London
and New York Theater tours, they offer The Vintage Car Club of
New Zealand Anniversary Tour and "The Soccer Holiday of a Lifetime."
You won't find those at your travel agent's! The tone of the writing
is relaxed, in the budget travel style, but note: these trips
ain't cheap. Still, visiting the site makes me feel that Oceania
is accessible -- even if I can't afford it.
Content: Excellent
Aesthetic: Good
TechnoSmart: Good
Author: Tom Geller
Back to top
Boat To Bolivia
With a title like "Boat to Bolivia," I expected swashbuckling
adventure -- or, at least, adventurous writing. Sad to say, Tracy
Morris is no adventurer, and her writing is about as thrilling
as your cousin's slide show. ("This is me in front of the house,
this is me in back of the house.") She relates the story of two
middle-class Brits making their way around the Americas, eventually
to (you guessed it!) Bolivia. Expect a slow server and scanned
postcards for graphics. The spelling and grammar are good, though.
Content: Good
Aesthetic: Good
TechnoSmart: Good
Author: Tom Geller
Back to top
Bridge
Now that Monk magazine and its imitators have gotten some recognition, on-the-road
writers are springing up all over the place. But how many of them
get around on bicycles laden with 125 pounds of crap? That's what
Holly Hughes and George MacLeod have done since 1993, covering
more than 35,000 miles, carrying a message of community art to
distant towns and writing, writing, writing about it. These folks
have real heart, and that's what makes this site great. Be sure
to check out Holly's statue/sculpture of Einstein, made of ballpoint
pens, tennis balls and 5-1/4" floppy disks: It's great fun, and
captures the site's spirit perfectly.
Content: Excellent
Aesthetic: Good
TechnoSmart: Good
Author: Tom Geller
Back to top
China
This site on China is much, much deeper than any other I've ever
seen. Sponsored by the Council on East Asian Libraries, it's broken
down into areas of interest, such as Art, History, Language, even
Gender Issues! Some pages are chock-full of links (the "Art" area
has several dozen), while other areas are a bit shallow. There
are similar pages on other major East Asian countries, at http://darkwing.uoregon.edu/~felsing/ceal/welcome.html.
Content: Excellent
Aesthetic: Good
TechnoSmart: Good
Author: Tom Geller
Back to top
The Electronic Embassy
The Electronic Embassy reminds me of a bank lobby: lots of space,
nice marble and brass fittings, and people in business clothes,
but there isn't much you can do there. It's a program of TeleDiplomacy
(a non-governmental organization) to serve the "diplomatic community"
in Washington, D.C. As such, it has some good, basic information.
But most pages eventually recommend that you call the appropriate
parties. Like, by phone, man. But I'm glad it's here: it's an
evenhanded and nonpolitical way of improving communication among
governments. And that ain't bad.
Content: Good
Aesthetic: Good
TechnoSmart: Good
Author: Tom Geller
Back to top
Expotel Home Page
Want to know about hotels in Zimbabwe? Check out Expotel, the
world's largest hotel and mobile phone reservation system. Well-heeled
travelers have quite a selection: seven high-quality tourist hotels
in the Dutch city of Rotterdam, for example, with prices ranging
from 87 to 290. But 87 to 290 what? This is a typical hole in
the site: nowhere does it tell you that prices are in the local
currency, in this case guilders. At the time of this writing,
the site had lots of hotels listed, but lacked some key information.
Keep an eye on it for improvements.
Content: Good
Aesthetic: Good
TechnoSmart: Good
Author: Tom Geller
Back to top
France Travel Tourism Tours Festivals Studies
Tourism is big business in France; that's why the French Tourism
Board in the U.S. is actively promoting its country via all media,
including the Internet. This site from that governmental body
is full of the kind of language you'd expect from a P.R. firm.
("This region abounds with treasures..," etc.) That's not to discount
it, though: there's tourism info (duh), stuff on studying in France,
and legal information you'll need about visas and such. None of
the areas is very deep, but they'll get you started. Beware the
occasional ghastly color scheme.
Content: Good
Aesthetic: Good
TechnoSmart: Good
Author: Tom Geller
Back to top
The French Travel Gallery & Hotel Reservation Center
I have an affinity for any site that welcomes you in more than
one language. The FTGHRC (gesundheit!) is one such site, offering
menus in French, English, and Spanish. Hélas, such multilingualism
fades away below the first level or two -- quelle dommage. What
is there is nicely arranged, though: hotel reservations, boutiques,
regional information, and, of course, the obligatory link to the
Webmuseum. Unfortunately, the content isn't nearly as deep as
it should be. And, as with most other hotel reservation systems,
this one isn't good at finding rooms at less than $50/night. Sigh.
Content: Good
Aesthetic: Good
TechnoSmart: Excellent
Author: Tom Geller
Back to top
GNN Travelers' Center American Borders
Travelogues are like voyages themselves: they can be brilliant,
witty adventures into unknown places or they can be hell, and
the difference is often made by the quality of your traveling
companions. I'm pleased to report that Carla King, author of GNN's
serial "American Borders," has created a distinct travelogue of
North America, as original as it is well-written. Making her way
around the continent on a Russian motorcycle, she reflects on
the foreignness of our country and writes up a storm. Lots of
photos spice up the tales, but there are virtually no links, even
within the text itself.
Content: Excellent
Aesthetic: Good
TechnoSmart: Poor
Author: Tom Geller
Back to top
GNN Travelers' Center Currency Converter
Globetrotters often return home wondering where all their money
went simply because they didn't understand the currency exchange.
This clever page helps you out by showing the value of American
dollars in the money of over 50 countries. You say you have Bulgarian
leva and want to know their value in Mexican pesos? No problem!
It would be useful to have the names of the currencies as well,
but hey -- we can't have everything. From the same mind as gave
the world the unofficial LEGO homepage at http://legowww.itek.norut.no/. Score two for David Koblas!
Content: Good
Aesthetic: Poor
TechnoSmart: Excellent
Author: Tom Geller
Back to top
GNN Travelers' Center Homepage
The Travelers' Center doesn't look that rich at first: just a
few links to articles and companies. But what makes it exciting
is that the articles (actually, first-person travel accounts)
are regularly updated, and the companies are off the beaten track.
Want to go hiking in Africa? Here, you can book the trip and read
stories to prepare you. A drawback: The site's organization requires
you to click through several screens to find what you want. Don't
overlook that link at the bottom, which leads to the "Travel"
section of GNN's business pages, and more links.
Content: Good
Aesthetic: Good
TechnoSmart: Good
Author: Tom Geller
Back to top
Guyana Gateway
Guyana is best known to U.S. residents for the religion-centered
mass murders in what is commonly known as "Jonestown." But then
again, we're not the best political/geography students in the
world, are we? The Guyana Gateway is a good place to increase
your I.Q. about this small Latin American country, located in
a wedge between Venezuela, Brazil, Surinam and the Atlantic Ocean.
It also sports one of the best uses of frames I've seen to date:
visit it with a frame-capable browser, such as Netscape 2.0 or
later (but try to ignore the ubiquitous "blink" tags, if you can).
Content: Excellent
Aesthetic: Good
TechnoSmart: Excellent
Author: Tom Geller
Back to top
Have Toothbrush Will Travel
If travel writer Rick Steves embodies the American spirit in traveling
-- fun, easygoing, out for a respectful good time -- then Simon
Rowe is his Australian counterpart. From him, you'll learn as
much about Australian culture as you will about his his destinations.
He's brash, opinionated, a bit obnoxious, and he writes a lot.
The site has about a dozen tastes of his writing, but it mostly
serves as a way for him to market his sixty-odd stories to interested
publications: he also does travel photography which is, sadly,
not displayed here.
Content: Good
Aesthetic: Poor
TechnoSmart: Good
Author: Tom Geller
Back to top
Healthy Flying
Flight discomfort is caused by more than just a fear of the plane
crashing into the mountains and leaving your remains a charred,
indistinguishable heap. Former flight attendant Diana Fairechild
has documented why flying is uncomfortable in her book, Jet Smart,
much of which is available in "quick tip" form via her Web page.
There's a neat bit of animation on the first page, but the focus
here is on the content -- be sure to read about the "Full utilization
of air," and how pilots can change the amount of air passengers
breathe. Scaaaary.
Content: Good
Aesthetic: Good
TechnoSmart: Good
Author: Tom Geller
Back to top
InfoHub Travel Guide
Hoo boy, yet another site proclaiming itself the "most comprehensive
travel guide on the World Wide Web." Unlike self-serving travel
agency sites, this one just might qualify. It's a plain-vanilla
set of pages which lists links to other travel-related sites:
very little information is at infohub.com. The links are arranged
by country, with colorful image maps to guide you as you bop from
continent to continent. I wish I had access to this site while
traveling: maybe a cellular modem connected to a PowerBook and
hooked directly into my brain. Bliss.
Content: Excellent
Aesthetic: Good
TechnoSmart: Good
Author: Tom Geller
Back to top
The Internet Guide to Travel
With a title like "The Internet Guide to Travel," I expected a
heck of a lot more. Like, maybe, some information about traveling.
But nooooo, all you get is a link to a hotel chain and an airline
(apparently, the service's only paying customers so far), and
a tiny bit of information about Hawaii and Los Angeles. Oh, wait:
Neither of those links seem to work. So, I guess there's nothing
here except for ugly banners, inconsistently done HTML, and an
ad to get prospective hotels to pay for listings.
Content: Poor
Aesthetic: Poor
TechnoSmart: Poor
Author: Tom Geller
Back to top
Internet Way
It takes a few minutes of wandering to realize that Internet Way
is an Internet Service Provider in France, offering access, Web
design, and the usual blah blah blah. But there are a few unusual
nuggets here of use to the traveler: Take a gander at the "Virtual
Champs-Elysées," which lets you walk in the door of dozens of
companies located along that famous street. There's lots of stuff
here about France in general, although the depth of info in this
section is disappointing when compared to the Champs-Elysées area.
But all in all, c'est magnifique!
Content: Excellent
Aesthetic: Excellent
TechnoSmart: Excellent
Author: Tom Geller
Back to top
Life Following the Dead
I've had a fantasy of collecting all my old letters, souvenirs,
photos, diaries and tape recordings to definitively archive my
life on a Web site. A full life is perhaps too ambitious to fully
document, but how about a road trip? That's what Joe Nickell has
done, transcribing copious notes of his adventures riding a Magic
Bus, following the Grateful Dead. What makes this site great is
the minutiae he captured in sound and imagery. Example: You not
only read, "Marty curses loudly," you also get to hear him. Awesome.
Content: Excellent
Aesthetic: Good
TechnoSmart: Excellent
Author: Tom Geller
Back to top
Mirage Resorts
Las Vegas is a singularly American place: In a terrain where there's
nothing of interest, attractions are invented and packaged. The
Mirage Hotel is a perfect epitome of this, in that (fake) European
food is served by a (fake) volcano while watching (real) tigers
in their (fake) environment. And it's all available for downloading!
Get the Mirage experience through pictures, sound bites, and QuickTime
video clips -- or buy t-shirts and plush tigers via their Web
site! You'll never have to leave the house. And isn't that what
you want in a vacation?
Content: Good
Aesthetic: Excellent
TechnoSmart: Good
Author: Tom Geller
Back to top
Preview Vacations
Boy, this site is pretty: pretty like a stuffed peacock. There
are over 500 colorful pages here, including destination information,
photos, multimedia stuff, and "real-time transaction capabilities."
But when you get down to the meat of things -- booking vacations
-- you're stuck with the usual, boring, pedestrian vacation standbys.
("Would you like the $100-per-night room in Paris or London?")
There are lots of clever forms and games to noodle with as well.
Fill out the survey: doing so enters you in a monthly drawing
for $1,000 worth of credit toward a Preview vacation.
Content: Good
Aesthetic: Excellent
TechnoSmart: Excellent
Author: Tom Geller
Back to top
Project Candide
Of all the "you are there" travel writing on the Internet, Project
Candide is one of the most ambitious. Here's the plot: five yuppie-ish
New Yorkers take off for Tanzania, to travel from Arusha to Zanzibar
armed with little more than money, their wits, and some very expensive
communications equipment. The result is.. well, some will find
it fun and some will find it patently offensive. (Our moneyed
friends sure do love those charming third-world natives!) If you
don't have a frames-capable browser, forget it: it's a multi-frame,
background-patterned, referential-URLed mess.
Content: Good
Aesthetic: Good
TechnoSmart: Excellent
Author: Tom Geller
Back to top
Rec.Travel Library: Worldwide Travel and Tourism
Newsgroups often have stewards who are kind and organized enough
to encapsulate community wisdom in a relevant FAQ file, but few
boast the riches that Internet Solutions has archived for this
Web-based rec.travel.* hierarchy. Besides the usual FAQs, it's
chock-full of information on lodging, travel, places to go, and
things to do. Unlike commercial travel sites, this one's not stingy
when it comes to linking outside sources: Thousands of them are
spread throughout literally hundreds of useful pages. If you don't
find what you need there, check out the rec.travel.* newsgroup
archives. And it's all searchable! For its friendliness and its
depth, this is one of the best sites I've seen all year.
Content: Excellent
Aesthetic: Good
TechnoSmart: Excellent
Author: Tom Geller
Back to top
Southwest Adventures
Does the thought of ice climbing appeal to you? How about mountain
kayaking? These activities are the purview of Southwest Adventures,
a Colorado firm that arranges outings for those sports which "can
only be enjoyed in the high mountains." Its products and recommendations
are described in exquisite detail, and links connect you to sites
and newsgroups of interest to the rugged soul. Despite occasional
misspellings (for example, "inable"), annoying blink tags, and
naive page design, Southwest Adventures' site does a good job
of bringing its offerings to the Net. Durango, ho!
Content: Excellent
Aesthetic: Poor
TechnoSmart: Poor
Author: Tom Geller
Back to top
Southwest Airlines
Southwest Airlines is famous for having the funniest "hold" messages
in the travel business: I once called, and heard, "If you have
a touch-tone phone, press eight. It won't make us respond faster,
but it'll make you feel better." Similarly, its home page has
the same sort of small-company irreverence: How many corporate
sites do you know of that feature a cartoon flight gate as its
main interface? Click on the cash register, and you find ticket
information; click on the wall map, and learn about the amenities
at Southwest's home airports; click on the company president's
photo, and you get, well, you get the photo. Fun and informative.
What more could you want?
Content: Excellent
Aesthetic: Good
TechnoSmart: Excellent
Author: Tom Geller
Back to top
Travel Source
Travel guides are popping up all over the Web, each promising
to be the biggest, best or otherwise most superlative. Travel
Source is no different. This commercial collection of links is
supposedly "The Internet's First Interactive Travel Guide." At
first, it seems that its pioneerism has given Travel Source time
to build quite a content base, but beneath the 35 categories of
travel information (from Wine Tours to Yacht Charters), there
are typically fewer than three links per category. Still, what
is there is reasonably diverse and interesting, even if it paints
an incomplete view of the wide world of travel options.
Content: Good
Aesthetic: Good
TechnoSmart: Good
Author: Tom Geller
Back to top
Travel Weekly
Is this a commercial site, or just the work of some travel agents
with too much time on their hands? The confusion stems from the
fact that 1) it's really, really well done; 2) it's sponsored
by a travel industry magazine; 3) you'll find no ads, and 4) it
features fun, sometimes sarcastic writing. So what's to dislike?
The site's accessibility, that's what. Several visits on two separate
days brought up the "this server isn't accepting any more connections"
message. Clearly, demand has outstripped supply. If you can get
through, though, you'll find the biggest set of travel links around.
If they'd fix a few links and beef up the server, this site would
rock.
Content: Excellent
Aesthetic: Good
TechnoSmart: Poor
Author: Tom Geller
Back to top
U.S State Department Travel Warnings
It may seem strange that the official repository of State Department
information is at St. Olaf's College in Minnesota, but it makes
sense when you consider that Travel Advisories have been available
through this site since 1991, long before the Internet was used
widely outside of universities. This site remains a prime source
of information for international-minded citizens. If you're a
regular traveler, you'll want to subscribe to the mailing list
that started it all: simply send an e-mail message that says only
"subscribe" to travel-advisories-request@stolaf.edu, and you'll get updates as they're released.
Content: Excellent
Aesthetic: Poor
TechnoSmart: Good
Author: Tom Geller
Back to top
Walt Disney World
If you know Disney, you know that everything it publishes is the
epitome of advertising hyperbole. Here you'll find the Web version:
clean graphics, professional (albeit vapid) copy writing, and
endless superlatives, all leveraging the highly bankable images
of Mickey Mouse and Pocahoozits. In keeping with Herr Disney's
vision of a perfectly controlled universe, there are no -- count
them, zero! -- external links. It's like visiting the Disney parks:
a nightmare of grinning cartoon characters, shiny buildings, clean
streets, and no way out. Stay in line, please. Children below
this height will not be allowed on this ride. You will be assimilated.
Have a nice day.
Content: Good
Aesthetic: Good
TechnoSmart: Good
Author: Tom Geller
Back to top
Web Travel Review
Philip Greenspun offers a good deal more than a "we-went-here-and-we-did-this"
report: There are travel tips, colorful photos, side stories --
like the fascinating tale of a criminal auto-repair shop -- and
lots of downright good writing. In the end, that's what sets this
site apart from other, more self-indulgent travelogues: The professional
level of the text and photos makes this site a special, moving
experience. But what's this guy doing studying artificial intelligence
at MIT? Conde Nast, sign him up!
Content: Excellent
Aesthetic: Excellent
TechnoSmart: Good
Author: Tom Geller
Back to top
This page was last updated on Monday, February 09, 2004 at 3:06pm CST.
All contents copyright 2005 by Tom Geller.
|