|
Home
Professional
P.R.
Writing
Speaking
Geeking
Terms
Other areas
About Tom
Contact info
Tom's other sites
bandwidthpr.com
spamcon.org
openppc.org
popcomputers.com
Mailing lists:
Tgeller-personal
Tgeller-business
Suespammers
|
|
Up one level | To Tom Geller's writings | Home
Website reviews for The Net: Political
Please note that the writing samples below were written around
February 1996, and many of the sites reviewed have disappeared,
moved, or changed. -- Tom Geller
The Atlantic Monthly
Bad Subjects
Center for Public Integrity
Congress in a Nutshell
The Drudge Report
The Fourth World Documentation Project
Government is Not God
Independent Candidates
The Atlantic Monthly
I visit dozens of sites every week, but rarely do I pause it any
one for more than five minutes. The Atlantic Monthly is different:
it captured me with its intriguing variety of content and held
me with the depth of its writing. Now in its 139th year (though
not on the Web that long, ha ha), its sense of history comes through:
there are archival reviews of 19th-century authors' works by their
contemporaries as well as modern fiction, poetry, and news commentary.
A "You are the President" game/survey and Election Connection
area keep the site relevant, and online exclusives make it even
better than the print version.
Content: Excellent
Aesthetic: Good
TechnoSmart: Excellent
Author: Tom Geller
Back to top
Bad Subjects
Every major university has an online journal these days, but only
U.C. Berkeley has Bad Subjects. A home for self-proclaimed leftists
in "reaction against some aspects of the academic left," the print
publication features l-o-o-o-n-g articles and not much else, while
a companion mailing list serves as a forum for action, reaction,
and general malaise. Both are archived at the Web site, and the
print publication can either be read online or (hooray!) downloaded
as an Adobe Acrobat PDF file. The site's design is minimal, yet
functional; the thought-provoking text is, appropriately, the
focus.
Content: Good
Aesthetic: Good
TechnoSmart: Excellent
Author: Tom Geller
Back to top
Center for Public Integrity
It's hard to examine politics without being partisan, but the
Center for Public Integrity -- dedicated to documenting the influences
weighing on presidential candidates -- does a pretty good job
of it. They primarily release findings in books and newsletters,
but unlike most publishers' Web sites, the CPI's documents are
available here in toto. Read about the hundreds of campaign advisors
(and their hidden agendas) in the 1996 presidential race, or download
a database of candidates' assets. Unfortunately, the designer's
love of graphics makes for long waits, and navigation can get
a bit tricky in places.
Content: Excellent
Aesthetic: Good
TechnoSmart: Good
Author: Tom Geller
Back to top
Congress in a Nutshell
"Congress in a Nutshell" -- sounds like a beginner's guide, doesn't
it? But don't let the innocuous name fool you: CIN is a place
for serious environmentalists to gather ammunition for their legislative
fights. There's almost no original material here, and the entire
archive rests on one page, but that doesn't diminish its utility;
with more than 100 links to relevant articles and sympathetic
organizations, you could spend days wandering the environmental
neighborhood. It's not the prettiest 'hood -- scarce graphics
and dense text may drive away all but the most dedicated activists
-- but a community nonetheless.
Content: Good
Aesthetic: Poor
TechnoSmart: Good
Author: Tom Geller
Back to top
The Drudge Report
You'd expect a name like "Matt Drudge" to be changed when its
owner took up residence in California, but from reading his newsletter
(available at this site and by e-mail), it's clear that Mr. Drudge
isn't changing himself for anybody. His occasional "tip sheet"
(published "when circumstances warrant") highlights a strange
mixture of news, notably politics, movies, and earthquakes (?).
But what's Mr. Drudge like? Well, he's a conservative, writing
a column for "The Right Side of the Web," yet he also provides
a link to Hillary Clinton's column. Check back often: you never
know what'll catch his attention.
Content: Good
Aesthetic: Poor
TechnoSmart: Good
Author: Tom Geller
Back to top
The Fourth World Documentation Project
Q: There are about 200 countries in the world. How many nations
are there? A: Over 5,000, according to this site, which uses the
term "Fourth World" to describe groups which have been forcibly
acculturated into more-powerful governments. While the Chippewa
and Aleuts may be familiar (and comparatively easy to track),
the FWDP carries extensive archives on lesser-known native peoples
of the world as well. There's a bit of an emphasis on indigenous
peoples of the U.S., but you'll also find plenty on tribes in
such places as Sweden and Peru. Includes a search engine.
Content: Excellent
Aesthetic: Good
TechnoSmart: Good
Author: Tom Geller
Back to top
Government is Not God
Did you know that prayer is banned in public schools? It isn't,
actually, but that erroneous belief is the basis for the "Government
is Not God" political action committee led by born-again Christian,
William Murray, son of famed atheist leader Madalyn Murray O'Hair
(!). Accuracy aside, the Web site is well-organized, although
the writing has the same propagandist flavor that taints most
political cant. Buttons are unclear in some places, and there
are few links to the outside world. Still, if you have $25 or
more burning a hole in your pocket and want to help elect "godly
men," this may be your oasis.
Content: Good
Aesthetic: Poor
TechnoSmart: Good
Author: Tom Geller
Back to top
Independent Candidates
A little annotation goes a long way, and its absence can make
the simplest matters cloudy as mud. So is the case with this site,
ostensibly designed to give independent presidential candidates
a much-needed forum. But there's no description of the sponsoring
organization ("Electronic Newspapers Inc."), navigation is inconsistent,
and the main page unfairly spotlights one of the six candidates.
(For the real main page, go to http://www.competition96.com/cand.htm.) It's a shame that there's so little clarification, because
the information contained here is important and far-reaching;
you just have to dig to find it.
Content: Good
Aesthetic: Good
TechnoSmart: Poor
Author: Tom Geller
Back to top
This page was last updated on Monday, February 09, 2004 at 3:06pm CST.
All contents copyright 2005 by Tom Geller.
|